Winners and losers in the English, Scottish and Welsh elections

·10 min read

The SNP has stormed ahead in the Scottish Parliament election, sparking demands for a second independence referendum and creating a constitutional clash with the Prime Minister.

Meanwhile, Labour has suffered local and by-election defeats described by one shadow minister as “shattering”, while coming out top in the Welsh Senedd and so far winning 10 of the 13 mayoral positions in England.

As votes continue to be counted throughout Sunday, the highlights for each election include:

Mayors

– Winners

Labour has dominated the mayoral elections, so far claiming 11 of the 13 posts being contested in cities and metropolitan regions across England versus two seats for the Tories.

Closely-fought contests in London and Cambridgeshire and Peterborough saw the polls go to second preferences, before Sadiq Khan triumphed over Conservative Shaun Bailey in London and Dr Nik Johnson beat Tory James Palmer with just 51.3% of the vote against Mr Palmer’s 48.7%.

London Mayoral election
Labour’s Sadiq Khan is hugged by one of his daughters (Victoria Jones/PA)

Labour incumbents Andy Burnham, Steve Rotheram, Marvin Rees, Norma Redfearn, Paul Dennett and Ros Jones retained their respective roles in Greater Manchester, Liverpool City Region, Bristol, North Tyneside, Salford and Doncaster.

Soap actress-turned-Labour MP Tracy Brabin also became the first Metro Mayor for West Yorkshire on her 60th birthday – a role she said she was “proud” and “humbled” to have secured.

Tories Andy Street and Ben Houchen also won landslide victories to retain their roles as West Midlands and Tees Valley mayors.

– Losers

London Mayoral election
Conservative Shaun Bailey shows his emotions after Labour’s Sadiq Khan won the Mayor of London contest (Victoria Jones/PA)

The battle to become London Mayor was much more closely fought than opinion polls suggested, and second-place Shaun Bailey said the contest showed that although journalists had him “written off”, he had gained considerable support from Londoners.

Incumbent James Palmer narrowly lost Cambridgeshire and Peterborough after gaining the most first preference votes – but not enough to secure his position before second preferences swung the vote in favour of Labour.

– Top tweet

Celebrating her victory in a tweet, Liverpool City’s new mayor, Joanne Anderson, confirmed she was “the first black woman to be directly-elected Mayor in the UK, and the first female Mayor of Liverpool. History made.”

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.
Update your settings here to see it.

– Best quote

Following her election, Ms Brabin said: “Growing up on free school meals, in a Birstall council flat, inspired by the Batley Variety Club to pursue life as an actor, I never imagined I would be elected as a Member of Parliament in my home town, let alone be asked to serve as the first ever metro mayor of West Yorkshire.”

Scottish Parliament

– Winners

The SNP claimed victory over the Tories in the Holyrood elections, and Nicola Sturgeon hailed their triumph as signalling the country’s demand for a second independence vote.

At 64 seats, the SNP was one shy of a majority, but placed them well ahead of the Tories who gained 31 seats and Labour who won 22.

Scottish Parliamentary Elections 2021
First Minister Nicola Sturgeon with the SNP’s Kaukab Stewart (Jane Barlow/PA)

New Glasgow Kelvin constituency MSP Kaukab Stewart also made Holyrood history as the first woman of colour to be elected to the Scottish Parliament – something she described as “an honour”.

– Top tweet

The Scottish Greens celebrated their best-ever election performance, returning eight MSPs including co-leader Lorna Slater who said she will be giving up her job as an engineering manager to take her seat.

In a video posted on Twitter she was shown enjoying a victory dance at Ingliston Highland Centre in Edinburgh.

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.
Update your settings here to see it.

– Losers

Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who has insisted he would not support an “irresponsible” second independence referendum, reacted to the SNP’s gains by inviting Ms Sturgeon for crisis talks on the Union in a letter shared on Twitter by Conservative MP Andrew Bowie.

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.
Update your settings here to see it.

Cabinet ministers Michael Gove and George Eustice have also hit out at Ms Sturgeon’s proposal, with Mr Gove telling the BBC’s Andrew Marr Show that “a majority of people who voted in the constituencies voted for parties that were opposed to a referendum” and Ms Sturgeon “didn’t secure a majority as Alex Salmond did in 2011″.

Mr Salmond failed this time round in his bid to return as an MSP for the recently formed Alba Party, which won just 8,269 votes.

– Best quote

Speaking after the SNP’s return to power, Nicola Sturgeon said: “It is the will of the country. Given that outcome, there is simply no democratic justification whatsoever for Boris Johnson or anyone else seeking to block the right of the people of Scotland to choose our future.”

Wales

– Winners

Senedd election
Wales First Minister Mark Drakeford elbow-bumps newly elected MS Labour candidates Elizabeth Buffy Williams, left, and Sarah Murphy in Porthcawl (Ben Birchall/PA)

Labour have come out top in the Senedd by winning 30 seats – just one short of a majority – equalling its best ever election result.

Welsh Labour put the “extraordinary set of results” down to the cautious approach during the coronavirus pandemic taken by First Minister Mark Drakeford, who has since called on Boris Johnson to “reset relationships” with the devolved nations.

Former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn also heralded Mr Drakeford’s re-election as “showing socialist values win in Wales” in a tweet.

– Losers

Scottish National Party Conference 2017
Plaid Cymru leader Leanne Wood lost her seat in the Senedd elections (Jane Barlow/PA)

High-profile former Plaid Cymru leader Leanne Wood lost her Rhondda seat to Labour’s Buffy Williams – though the party now has 13 seats in the Welsh Parliament.

On her Facebook page, Ms Wood said the result was “disappointing” but that her team could “hold our heads high in the knowledge that we ran a clean and honest campaign, we did not denigrate our opponents and we worked hard”.

– Top tweet

Shadow foreign secretary Lisa Nandy shared a touching photograph of Welsh Labour’s health minister Vaughan Gething celebrating holding his Cardiff South and Penarth seat with his six-year-old son on Twitter.

Ms Nandy tweeted: “Amidst a difficult set of election results, it’s been lovely to watch some of the well-deserved celebrations amongst our Welsh Labour friends.”

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.
Update your settings here to see it.

– Best quote

Welsh Labour leader Mark Drakeford said: “This really is a moment that the Prime Minister should seize to reset relationships across the United Kingdom, for a serious examination of the way in which we can create the machinery that will allow us to work together in the future.”

England local councils

– Losers

In stark contrast to the party’s performance in the mayoral elections and in Wales, Labour’s losses at the local council elections in England have thrown the party into turmoil.

After announcing he was “bitterly disappointed” with the results, leader Sir Keir Starmer reshuffled his shadow cabinet in a move which saw Rachel Reeves promoted to chancellor and former incumbent Anneliese Dodds relegated to party chairman.

Deputy leader Angela Rayner was also fired as party chairman and elections co-ordinator, and took Ms Reeves’ former post as shadow chancellor to the Duchy of Lancaster, while chief whip Nick Brown was sacked from the cabinet altogether.

Ms Rayner’s sacking sparked criticism from Labour’s left, including former shadow chancellor John McDonnell, while previous leader Mr Corbyn suggested Sir Keir’s Labour Party was “offering nothing” to voters.

The party’s losses included Southampton City Council.

– Winners

In an unprecedented move for a party in power for more than a decade, the Tories had 12 net council gains in England and more than 280 seats.

Many of the party’s wins in England were snatched from Labour – which made a net loss of six councils and more than 220 seats – including Amber Valley, Harlow and Southampton.

Hartlepool by-election
Boris Johnson in front of a giant inflatable of himself (Owen Humphreys/PA)

The Conservatives also took control of some councils such as Cannock Chase for the first time.

Labour did make some gains – including Geoff Saul narrowly winning a county council seat from the Conservatives in Chipping Norton, in the affluent Cotswold area where former prime minister David Cameron lives.

The Liberal Democrats also gained one seat compared with the last elections after taking control of St Albans, with party leader Sir Ed Davey set to make an appearance in the Hertfordshire town to celebrate.

Scottish Parliamentary Elections 2021
Leader of the Liberal Democrats Sir Ed Davey will be visiting St Albans after his party gained control of the council there on Sunday (Jane Barlow/PA)

– Best quote

Prime Minister Boris Johnson said: “Voters have put their trust in Conservative representatives, councillors and mayors and we must deliver for them… There will be no let up in levelling up.”

– Top tweet

In Norfolk, election staff “limbered up” for the count by dancing to the Macarena and followed the result with a Mexican wave, as shown in videos posted by South Norfolk Council’s Twitter page.

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.
Update your settings here to see it.

By-election

– Winners

Conservative candidate Jill Mortimer seized the Hartlepool seat from Labour after the party had held it for more than 50 years.

Ms Mortimer overturned a majority of 3,500 at the general election to take the seat – which had been Labour-held since it was formed in 1974 – with a majority of 6,940.

Hartlepool by-election
Conservative Jill Mortimer addressed the media in Hartlepool after being declared winner (Owen Humphreys/PA)

The importance of the contest was underlined by both Mr Johnson and Sir Keir making repeated visits to the constituency during the course of the campaign.

– Top tweet

The Prime Minister welcomed Ms Mortimer to his Government in a tweet, adding: “It’s time to get to work to deliver on the people’s priorities”.

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.
Update your settings here to see it.

– Losers

For Labour, the loss symbolised another brick falling from its “red wall” to Mr Johnson’s Tories, in a defeat one shadow minister described as “heart-breaking”.

Sir Keir said he was determined to address the problems within his party after candidate Dr Paul Williams lost the contest.

Keir Starmer visit to the North East
Sir Keir Starmer and Dr Paul Williams, the Labour Party candidate for Hartlepool (Ian Forsyth/PA)

He said: “I’m bitterly disappointed in the result and I take full responsibility for the results – and I will take full responsibility for fixing this.”

– Best quote

Speaking after the result, Steve Reed, shadow housing secretary, said: “There’s no hiding from the fact this is a shattering result for Labour, absolutely shattering, and for a town like Hartlepool that’s been Labour for half a century to now be in Conservative hands is heart-breaking for anybody who is Labour.”