The rules, as host Tracy explained, were simple: Either answer the question truthfully, or take a shot. Whiskey, tequila, orange liqueur, bitters and lime juice were all available options.
Schwartz was asked if he’d rather be stranded on an island with fellow cast members Kristen Doute or James Kennedy. He picked Kristen. “She’s wily and she’s resourceful,” he explained. “She was the second person I met in Los Angeles, she’s like family.”
Later, Tracy asked both of them to come clean about the most famous person who has slid into their DMs. Schwartz opted for a shot of whiskey. Maloney instead gave up a name, and what a name it was: Rihanna. “It’s sacred,” Schwartz chimed in.
As for whether or not either of them could pick a past experience to erase, Schwartz at first chose the time he gave Katie a “ring on a string” but then backed down, calling the moment “cute and thoughtful.”
Each week on Yahoo Entertainment, sit down with your favorite reality stars and get the scoop in the best way we know how — trivia! Reality Star Showdown is produced by Ellen Digital Network and distributed on Yahoo Entertainment.
Read more from Yahoo Entertainment:
Want daily pop culture news delivered to your inbox? Sign up here for Yahoo Entertainment & Lifestyle's newsletter.