UK butterflies vanish from nearly half of the places they once flew – study

<span>Photograph: Mark Mirror/Getty Images</span>
Photograph: Mark Mirror/Getty Images

Butterfly species have vanished from nearly half of the places where they once flew in the UK since 1976, according to a study.

The distribution of 58 native species has fallen by 42% as butterflies disappear from cities, fields and woods. Those that are only found in particular habitats, such as wetlands or chalk grassland, have fared even worse, declining in distribution by 68%.

Scientists for Butterfly Conservation, which produced its State of the UK’s Butterflies 2022 report from nearly 23m butterfly records, said there needed to be a “massive step-change” to reverse what it described as disastrous declines in insect populations.

The report shows that many of the most endangered species have been revived by targeted conservation action or successfully reintroduced in specific places, but butterflies and other flying insects continue to vanish from much of Britain.

The grayling fell by 92% in distribution and 72% in abundance between 1976 and 2019
The grayling fell by 92% in distribution and 72% in abundance between 1976 and 2019. Photograph: FLPA/Alamy

“We’ve been focused on the most threatened butterfly species, which is stopping them going extinct,” said Richard Fox of Butterfly Conservation, the lead author of the report. “But there’s a massive challenge revealed by millions of pieces of data in the report, and we need a massive step change in our approach to tackle this and meet the legally binding government target that now exists for halting the decline of wildlife. This report shows we are not halting the decline of wildlife.”

The overall figure for the decline in butterfly abundance is a relatively modest 6%, but this average figure is obtained from data gathered from nature reserves and nature-rich landscapes, which masks wider population falls.

Species such as the wood white, grayling, wall, white admiral and pearl-bordered fritillary have suffered precipitous declines in both distribution and abundance. The grayling fell by 92% in distribution and 72% in abundance between 1976 and 2019.

A pearl-bordered fritillary
A pearl-bordered fritillary. Photograph: Forestry Commission/PA

There have been some successes, linked to climate change or concerted conservation action. Beneficiaries of global heating, which has facilitated their expansion further north through Britain, include strong-flying species such as the purple emperor, whose distribution is up by 58% and abundance by 110%, and the comma , whose distribution is up by 94% and abundance by 203%.

Conservation triumphs include the large blue, which was reintroduced using caterpillars from Sweden after its extinction in 1979. Its abundance has risen by 1,883%.

The large blue has been a conservation success
The large blue has been a conservation success. Photograph: Keith Warmington/PA

But in many cases, although targeted conservation work on certain nature reserves has increased the abundance of rare butterflies, they have continued to vanish from other places, their range shrinking and their populations losing resilience as a result.

The swallowtail has increased in abundance by 51%, doing well on nature reserves which are precisely managed to meet its needs, but its distribution or presence in the wider landscape has shrunk by 27%. Chalk grassland specialists such as the silver-spotted skipper and adonis blue have increased in abundance by 596% and 130% respectively, but their distribution has fallen by 70% and 44%. This shows that they are no longer able to survive in a large proportion of their former haunts, nor are they able to colonise new areas.

A swallowtail
A swallowtail. Photograph: Kevin Elsby/Alamy

The biggest butterfly declines are in England. The picture looks more positive in Scotland, where species have, on average, increased in abundance by 37% and in distribution by 3%.

But Fox said these figures were caused by the huge successes of a few species, such as the comma and the white-letter hairstreak, which have been able to move further north with climate change. “It’s not a cause for celebration,” he said. “Butterflies that you might think of as iconic examples of Scotland’s natural heritage such as the mountain ringlet, Scotch argus and northern brown argus are all doing really badly.

“UK butterflies are by far the best, most comprehensively monitored group of insects anywhere in the world. Butterflies are fulfilling that really important role as an indicator for thousands of other species and the general state of our environment. This report is very gloomy reading on that front.

An Adonis blue
An adonis blue. Photograph: Richard Becker/Alamy

“It’s going to need bold moves by government and everyone to take responsibility. Everyone with a garden can help, but the scale of the biodiversity crisis is such that planting a few pollinator-friendly plants is not enough. We need to create habitat where butterflies and other wildlife can live and not just visit for a snack.”

Julie Williams, the chief executive of Butterfly Conservation, said: “This report is yet more compelling evidence of nature’s decline in the UK. We are totally dependent on the natural world for food, water and clean air. We need swift and effective action on this. The decline in butterflies we have seen in our own lifetimes is shocking and we can no longer stand by and watch the UK’s biodiversity be destroyed.”