Two-dose passport 'almost worthless': Ottawa medical experts call for three-dose document

CBC
·2 min read
Some medical experts in Ottawa are calling for Ontario to update its vaccine passport to require three doses to gain entry to a range of non-essential venues. (Evan Mitsui/CBC - image credit)
Some medical experts in Ottawa are calling for Ontario to update its vaccine passport to require three doses to gain entry to a range of non-essential venues. (Evan Mitsui/CBC - image credit)

Some Ottawa-area public health experts would like to see the province's COVID-19 vaccine passport require Ontarians have a booster shot in order to enter a range of indoor establishments.

Premier Doug Ford announced Thursday the province will begin lifting public health restrictions at the end of the month, and said no changes to the two-dose requirement are currently planned.

"Fish or cut bait," said Dr. Doug Manuel, an epidemiologist and senior scientist at The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute. "[A] two-dose passport is almost worthless…You might as well just throw it away — or you bring the three-dose."

Several indoor settings will reopen at 50 per cent capacity on Jan. 31 to those with two doses of a COVID-19 vaccine. The province plans to lift most restrictions by mid-March.

Submitted by Doug Manuel
Submitted by Doug Manuel

Manuel said two doses of COVID-19 vaccine is not enough protection to prevent Omicron cases from surging once current restrictions are lifted. Two doses, he said, are only about 20 per cent effective in protecting against Omicron infection, although the same dosage is more effective in protecting against severe infection and hospitalizations.

"There's a universal agreement with epidemiologists that if we lift [restrictions] off too quickly, we're just going to surge." Manuel said.

The Ontario Ministry of Health didn't respond to a request for comment in time for publication.

Three-dose passport supported elsewhere in region

Medical officers of health for Renfrew County and Eastern Ontario Health Units echoed Manuel's position.

"If we can mandate two vaccines, we can move ahead with three," said Dr. Robert Cushman, acting medical officer of health for Renfrew County. "What we've seen is that people who've had a third vaccine do very well."

Cushman said "ample" evidence suggests healthcare workers who are struggling to return to work after being infected by COVID-19 are less likely to have received a booster dose.

"If we have more vaccination, we have more protection and less serious disease from Omicron," he added.

A spokesperson for eastern Ontario medical officer of health Dr. Paul Roumeliotis said the health unit's top doctor also supports a third dose for vaccine passports.

Leeds, Grenville and Lanark medical officer of health Dr. Paula Stewart was not available for comment. Ottawa Public Health opted not to take a position on the issue.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • Travel chaos at airports across UK - as London and Manchester confirm nationwide border issue

    Chaos has been reported at airports across the UK - as two airports have confirmed a nationwide border issue.

  • Twilio stock slips on Q2 revenue outlook

    Shares of Twilio (TWLO) are moving to the downside in after-hours trading on Tuesday. For the first quarter, the cloud communications company reported adjusted earnings per share of $0.80, topping estimates of $0.60. Revenue of $1.05 billion was just slightly better than the $1.03 billion estimate.  The second quarter revenue outlook was slightly disappointing, however. The company forecasts revenue of $1.05 billion to $1.06 billion short of the $1.08 billion estimate. For more expert insight and the latest market action, click here to watch this full episode of Market Domination. This post was written by Angel Smith

  • Palantir shares post biggest daily slide since 2022 after forecast disappoints

    Shares of Palantir Technologies fell 15.1% on Tuesday in their biggest daily percentage drop since May 2022, a day after the data analytics company gave a revenue forecast that disappointed. Still, several brokerages raised their price targets following the report, including D.A. Davidson, which raised its target to $24 from $19. "While guidance for FY2024 was increased, it was lighter than expected," D.A. Davidson analysts wrote in their research note, adding that management had noted "they're seeing unavoidable headwinds in Europe."

  • Reddit’s first quarterly earnings since going public: revenue and users increase

    Social networking company reported $575m in losses, but strong revenue and an increase in users buoyed investor confidence

  • Apple's 2023 iMac drops to a record-low price

    Apple's 2023 iMac has dropped to its lowest price to date, but you'll need to be comfortable having just 8GB of RAM.

  • Deputies: Volusia woman found with dead pets in home likely only fed them '3 or 5 times a week'

    Deputies: Volusia woman found with dead pets in home likely only fed them '3 or 5 times a week'

  • CANADA STOCKS-TSX edges closer to record high as resource shares advance

    Canada's main stock index rose for a fifth straight day on Tuesday, edging closer to a new record high, as investors grew confident that a rally in heavily-weighted resource shares could be sustained. The Toronto Stock Exchange's S&P/TSX composite index ended up 31.15 points, or 0.1%, at 22,290.62, extending a string of gains since last Wednesday. "If you have two out of those three categories that are working, you've got a good market," said Philip Petursson, chief investment strategist at IG Wealth Management.

  • Proxy battle was a 'win-win': Disney shareholder

    Despite weak parks and cruise guidance, Disney's (DIS) second quarter earnings saw its streaming services, Disney+ and Hulu, turn a profit for the first time. Blanke Schein Wealth Management Chief Investment Officer Robert Schein joins Market Domination to break down the market reaction to the entertainment giant's earnings. Schein sees the sliding Disney stock as an overreaction stemming from Wall Street's disappointment in the company's weaker-than-expected guidance. Nonetheless, he stresses that Disney had a "solid" second quarter and is still trending higher year-to-date for long-term shareholders. Fresh off Disney's victory in a hotly contested proxy battle with activist investor Nelson Peltz, Schein — who voted for Peltz — believes the situation ended in a "win-win." "[Peltz] basically got management's attention," he explains, adding, "Moving forward, I believe wholeheartedly management's going to execute." For more expert insight and the latest market action, click here to watch this full episode of Market Domination. This post was written by Melanie Riehl

  • David Duchovny's new podcast is about failure. Here's how he's learned to 'embrace' it.

    At 63, the star says he's "finally just heeding my own advice and doing things that are authentic to me and not doing the things that are not."

  • Chaos at UK airports after Border Force gates fail causing long queues

    Pictures showed queues at Heathrow, Gatwick, Stansted, Luton, Edinburgh and Manchester

  • Drake’s security guard shot in drive-by days after Kendrick Lamar doxxed rapper’s mansion in diss track cover

    Shooting came just days after Kendrick Lamar doxxed Drake’s home in a diss track against him amid an ongoing feud between the two rappers

  • Trump trial live updates: 'None of it is made up,' Stormy Daniels says of her story

    Former President Donald Trump is on trial in New York City, where he is facing felony charges related to a 2016 hush money payment to adult film actress Stormy Daniels. Trump last April pleaded not guilty to a 34-count indictment charging him with falsifying business records in connection with a hush money payment his then-attorney Michael Cohen made to Daniels in order to boost his electoral prospects in the 2016 presidential election. Former President Trump was conferring with his attorney when Stormy Daniels passed by the defense table on her way out of the courtroom, and she and Trump did not appear to acknowledge each other.

  • Talk it out: Oro-Medonte prepares for provincial facilitator meeting

    Even though a formal invitation has yet to arrive, Oro-Medonte Township council is preparing for a meeting with a provincial land facilitator to discuss the City of Barrie’s proposed boundary expansion plan. In his report, which will be presented Wednesday afternoon at the township's council meeting, George Vadeboncoeur, manager of planning special projects, is recommending council: “The provincial facilitation process allows an objective third party to review and discuss the proposals and alter

  • Province seeks Meta's support during emergencies

    The province says it's working with Meta, the company that owns the social media platforms Facebook and Instagram, to ensure important information is distributed to its users during times of emergency, such as wildfires. Last year, the social media giant announced it was ending news availability on its platforms in Canada, after the federal government passed the Online News Act, or Bill C-18, requiring big tech companies to pay media outlets for news content that is shared on their platforms.Tha

  • TikTok sues U.S. government. What does it mean for the potential ban of the platform?

    TikTok filed a lawsuit on Tuesday, seeking a court order to stop the U.S. government from enforcing a ban on the app. Here's what comes next.

  • Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp signs sweeping election overhaul bill as ACLU threatens to sue

    Gov. Brian Kemp's decision to sign his party's bill came at the last minute.

  • White house piles ceasefire pressure on Netanyahu as tanks roll into Rafah

    The US has piled pressure on Benjamin Netanyahu to agree a ceasefire deal with Hamas, arguing the two sides should be able to “close the remaining gaps” in negotiations “very soon”.

  • Co-op Live: Travis Scott gig announced, amid opening issues

    Several artists have cancelled shows at the Manchester venue, as its opening has been delayed.

  • Teenager shot in head and killed in broad daylight attack in Manhattan by suspects riding Citi Bikes

    The teen was pronounced dead after being taken to Bellevue Hospital for treatment

  • Brewers first baseman Black overwhelmed by support from Canadian fans after MLB debut

    It was like something out of a storybook. Tyler Black was at the plate in his big league debut with the Milwaukee Brewers as his father, former TSN broadcaster Rod Black, and his mother Nancy Black, were being interviewed in the stands. The younger Black connected on his second hit of the game, and of his career, and his father's instincts took over, immediately calling the play. "There's a base hit to right field for my boy, Tyler Black," said Rod Black. "There you go, oh there you go, 2 for 2.