Trump’s taxes: Why they matter to a criminal probe

Joshua Nevett - BBC News
·5 min read
Former US President Donald Trump
Prosecutors in New York have been investigating Donald Trump since 2018

A criminal investigation into the financial affairs of former US President Donald Trump and his family business gained momentum this week.

On Monday the Supreme Court ordered Mr Trump to hand over his tax returns and other financial records to prosecutors in New York.

The ruling was a setback for Mr Trump, who had sought to prevent prosecutors from seeing his records for months.

The records are considered to be central to the criminal investigation.

They could be "a pretty important piece of the puzzle", Daniel R Alonso, a former US federal and New York state prosecutor, told the BBC.

You may be asking: what is this criminal investigation, and what is the significance of Mr Trump's records?

Here, we explain what it's all about.

What is the investigation?

Let's start with the basics.

This is a criminal investigation being carried out by prosecutors in the state of New York.

Cyrus Vance, the Democratic district attorney of Manhattan, is the lead prosecutor in the investigation.

He and his team are merely looking into the possibility of crimes at the moment.

Mr Trump, a Republican, has continuously denied wrongdoing and suggested the investigation is politically motivated.

Cyrus Vance
Cyrus Vance has been leading a criminal investigation into the Trump Organization since 2018

As part of the investigation, Mr Vance is examining the financial and tax affairs of Mr Trump and his family business, the Trump Organization.

It is one of two known criminal investigations into Mr Trump. The other concerns alleged attempts by Mr Trump to overturn results from last November's presidential election in the state of Georgia.

How did we get here?

The investigation began in 2018, when Mr Trump was still president.

At first, the investigation examined the Trump Organization's role in hush-money payments made during the 2016 presidential campaign to two women who said they had had affairs with Mr Trump.

Michael Cohen - Mr Trump's former personal lawyer - was jailed for his role in the scheme under federal, or national, laws in 2018.

Meanwhile, Mr Vance has been assessing whether the Trump Organization broke any state laws in New York in relation to the payoffs.

So that's it? No, not quite.

Mr Vance's investigation has widened to include other possible crimes.

The New York Times, citing unnamed sources, said Mr Vance had "been examining whether Mr Trump, his company and its employees committed insurance, tax and banking fraud, among other crimes".

This is where the tax and financial records come in.

Mr Vance needs them to establish if any crimes have been committed.

For months he has been trying to obtain eight years' worth of Mr Trump's personal and corporate tax returns.

Last July, the Supreme Court ruled that Mr Trump's records could be examined by the prosecutor's office.

But lawyers representing Mr Trump challenged that ruling, suggesting that the court filing was "wildly overbroad" and issued in bad faith.

On Monday, the court rejected that argument.

The US Supreme Court
The Supreme Court ruling has paved the way for prosecutors to begin combing through Mr Trump's financial records

The ruling means Mr Vance can gain access to the records, allowing him and his team to pore over them.

"The significance is quite large," Mr Alonso said of the ruling. "I mean that in the sense that it is significant and there are going to be a lot of documents. These documents could be in the millions."

In a succinct statement addressing the ruling, Mr Vance said: "The work continues."

By contrast, Mr Trump dismissed the investigation as a "political witch hunt".

What could prosecutors learn from the tax records?

The records will give prosecutors a fuller picture of Mr Trump's financial affairs.

For example, prosecutors may be able to explore certain investigative theories, seek interviews with witnesses, and establish whether any state laws have been violated.

As well as Mr Trump's tax returns, analysis by accountants and their communications with their client could be included in the tranche of records, Mr Alonso said.

"All that stuff is going to be important, given the allegations that are out there," he said.

We know from court filings that Mr Vance has mentioned tax fraud as a hypothetical crime, should evidence be found to support it.

People walk by a Trump-owned property on Wall Street
Mr Vance has been looking into the financial affairs of Mr Trump and his family business for two years

Many wealthy Americans use loopholes to reduce the amount of tax they are legally bound to pay.

But the records could be crucial in determining the legality of accounting methods Mr Trump and his company may have used.

It will take time for investigators to review the records. Given this, the investigation could run beyond the end of Mr Vance's term as an elected district attorney late this year.

So, as you can probably tell, much remains unclear.

How serious could this be for Trump?

"It's not one to be taken lightly," Mr Alonso said. "Clearly, it's a substantial investigation."

At this point, it is not clear whether prosecutors will file any criminal charges against Mr Trump, his company, or his business partners.

The investigation may come to nothing.

However, if prosecutors do find evidence of wrongdoing, criminal proceedings are a possibility.

In New York, some types of tax fraud can be charged as crimes known as felonies, which can carry lengthy prison sentences.

Hypothetically, Mr Trump could be summoned to court for a criminal trial in New York, in the event he is charged.

This outcome - albeit theoretical at this point - would seriously undermine Mr Trump's chances of a political comeback.

At the moment, though, Mr Trump's tax records merely give Mr Vance's office the opportunity to expand its investigation, nothing else.