Top Jan. 6 federal judge slams DOJ for treating 'crime of the century' as some 'petty offense'

Peter Weber, Senior editor
·2 min read

Judge Beryl Howell, the chief judge of the federal District Court in Washington, D.C., sentenced Jan. 6 rioter Jack Griffith to three years of probation on Thursday, but she clearly wasn't happy about it. Prosecutors had requested three months in jail for the crime Griffith pleaded guilty to, "parading" — or demonstrating inside of the Capitol — but Howell said her "hands are tied" because prosecutors had requested probation for other defendants who pleaded guilty to similarly light second-tier misdemeanors.

"Probation should not be the norm," Howell said. "In all my years on the bench, I've never been in this position before, and it's all due to the government, despite calling this the crime of the century, resolving it with a . . . petty offense" that would normally be resolved with a $50 fine. Even the government's $500 fines for most Jan. 6 defendants are excessively lenient, she said, noting they would only raise as much as $300,000 of the $500 million taxpayers will shell out to secure the Capitol.

More than anything, Howell sharply questioned the Justice Department's "muddled" and "almost schizophrenic" prosecution strategy. "No wonder parts of the public in the U.S. are confused about whether what happened on Jan. 6 at the Capitol was simply a petty offense of trespassing with some disorderliness, or shocking criminal conduct that represented a grave threat to our democratic norms," she said. "Let me make my view clear: The rioters were not mere protesters."

"Everyone participating in the mob contributed to that violence," Howell said, and "the damage to the reputation of our democracy, which is usually held up around the world . . . that reputation suffered because of Jan. 6."

Howell, an Obama appointee, "has taken a leading role in pressing prosecutors to consider the broader threat to democracy that the riot presented when considering charges and punishment for participants," Politico reports. But in a separate Jan. 6 case on Thursday, Trump appointee Judge Trevor McFadden got tart with two defendants, Rachel Lynn Pert and Dana Joe Winn of Florida, for requesting to be sentenced over video.

"Defendants found the means to travel to Washington, D.C., to commit the crime to which they have pled guilty," McFadden wrote. "Defendants can therefore find the means to return to Washington, D.C., to be held accountable for this crime."

You may also like

5 riotously funny cartoons about Steve Bannon's contempt of Congress charge

How Germany is beating COVID, and what America can learn

The 'Trump app' will be the insurrection on steroids

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • In Court, Donald Trump Is a Loser—and Alone

    Illustration by Elizabeth Brockway/The Daily BeastIf you were a rioter at the United States Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, you may have felt the whole world was with you—or the part of the world that supported what you did.President Trump himself had urged you to march to the Capitol Building. A crowd walked alongside you down Pennsylvania Avenue. People chanted with you about attacking Mike Pence, crashed through the police lines with you, helped you to break windows and march through the building.Af

  • Grieving families looking for answers after report alleges doctor denied life-saving transplants

    Grieving families spoke at a press conference on April 24 of their search for answers after the New York Times published an article on April 18, alleging Dr. J. Steve Bynon Jr. of Memorial Hermann-Texas Medical Center of manipulating records to ensure select patients became ineligible for receiving transplants.

  • Nevada GOP Senate Hopeful Uses Campaign Cash to Cosplay as a Cowboy

    Photo Illustration by Thomas Levinson/The Daily Beast/Getty/Dr. Jeff Gunter For US SenateWhen he launched his campaign for U.S. Senate in Nevada last year, Jeff Gunter presented himself as a gritty frontiersman and a diehard MAGA Republican.Gunter’s opening video depicts him stepping into a Ford F-150 pickup truck—cowboy boots and all—admiring the bucolic western landscape in a burgundy button-down as he talks about his credentials. And in case you had somehow forgotten which state’s Senate seat

  • Third man is detained in a major bribery case that involves Russia's deputy defense minister

    A third man has been detained in a bribery case involving a Russian deputy defense minister, Moscow's court service said Thursday. It said businessman Alexander Fomin is suspected of paying bribes to Deputy Defense Minister Timur Ivanov, who was detained on Wednesday, as well as Ivanov's associate, Sergei Borodin. Ivanov, an ally of Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu, was jailed pending an investigation and trial on charges of bribery, court officials said in a statement.

  • Frontline Ukrainians Fear New Aid From U.S. Will Be a Disaster

    Anatolii Stepanov/AFP via Getty ImagesKHARKIV, Ukraine—After months of infighting on Capitol Hill, President Joe Biden has finally been able to sign off on a huge new $61 billion military aid bill for Ukraine. Delays to the bill, which got bogged down in the Republican-controlled House of Representatives, were widely blamed for impacting Kyiv’s ability to defend itself from Russian advances. After its passage last week, some members of the House waved Ukrainian flags while others cheered in cele

  • UPDATE 1-UK-listed drugmaker Indivior seeks shareholder nod for US listing

    UK-listed drugmaker Indivior plans to seek shareholder approval next month for a primary listing in the United States, the company said on Thursday, which would add it to a growing list of firms leaving the London stock market. Indivior had, in February, announced its intent to shift its listing by the middle of the year to the U.S., which, it argued, reflected its growth opportunities as its proprietary treatments are U.S.-centred and U.S.-based investors account for nearly 50% of its overall shareholder base. The list of UK-based companies that have already listed in the United States includes ARM, the UK's biggest chip company, as well as building supplies firm CRH and plumbing equipment company Ferguson.

  • Scotland's powersharing deal collapses in bust-up between Greens and SNP

    The Bute House Agreement brought the Green Party into government for the first time anywhere in the UK

  • Bogus Furry Panic Overtakes Utah School District

    Photo Illustration by Thomas Levinson/The Daily Beast/GettyLast Wednesday, dozens of students skipped class to gather outside a Payson, Utah, middle school for hours and chant, “We the people, not the animals!”—a protest launched over the dramatic accusation that their classmates were running wild as “furries” and attacking other students without consequence.Much of the hysteria, however, has been blown out of proportion.Footage from the scene showed them hoisting signs declaring, “Compelled spe

  • Bristol Bears star Simi Pam admits she considered retirement amid injury woes

    Bristol Bears star Simi Pam admits she considered walking away from rugby after a serious ankle injury derailed her international dreams.

  • Before Trump’s Big Lie, There Was Trump, the Big Liar

    Photo Illustration by Luis G. Rendon/The Daily Beast/Getty ImagesThe first stages of the trial of the People of New York State vs. Donald J. Trump have been illuminating in a variety of ways. They have made it absolutely clear that this trial is not the legal non-event Republicans and drinkers of conventional wisdom-flavored Kool Aid said it was.It is not a case about “paperwork” or “bookkeeping.” It is not a bland little nothingburger of arcane, hard-to-prove white-collar crime. It is not just

  • Venezuela broke its HPV vaccine promises, and there's barely any sex ed. Experts say it's a problem

    Some of the 10 women and teenage girls who recently came to a medical clinic in eastern Venezuela for free contraceptives fidgeted a bit when a community health worker taught them how to use an IUD, condoms and birth control pills correctly. The health worker also asked what they knew about HPV, the most common sexually transmitted infection in the world and the cause of nearly all cervical cancer. Of the 10, ages 16 to 33 — two of whom had traveled to Putucual by boat and bus — only one had learned about human papillomavirus in middle school.

  • Trump allies Meadows and Giuliani indicted in Arizona over 2020 election interference as trial resumes - live

    Former president’s historic ‘hush money’ election interference trial is underway in New York

  • London travel news LIVE: Euston rush-hour disruption after train hits obstruction near Watford Junction

    Disruption has hit the morning rush-hour on Thursday after a train crashed into an obstruction near Watford. Trains to and from Euston are among those affected. National Rail warns trains are having to run at reduced speeds on the line towards Milton Keynes Central.

  • Snap up John Lewis's 'excellent' heated clothes airer while it's only £75

    After selling out multiple times, this popular airer is now back in stock for a reduced price, and available with free delivery.

  • London mayor election: Sadiq Khan's lead smallest over Susan Hall since campaigns started, new poll shows

    Exclusive Savanta survey for the Mile End Institute at Queen Mary University of London put the Labour mayor on 46 per cent, with his Tory challenger on 33 per cent, a lead of 13 points

  • Hospital move for patients with blood disorders

    Haematology patients in Poole will soon be sent to Bournemouth under streamlining plans.

  • Israel-Gaza – live: US demands ‘answers’ from Israel over mass graves at hospitals as Rafah offensive looms

    The Israeli army said any suggestion of its responsibility for the mass graves was ‘baseless’ and ‘unfounded’

  • London horses – live: Runaway horses in serious condition but still alive minister says

    Cavalry horses Vida and Quaker were seen running in the road near Aldwych on Wednesday morning

  • Scottish government coalition collapses as SNP end power-sharing with Greens

    The decision came after first minister Mr Yousaf called an emergency meeting of the Scottish cabinet to address growing tensions between the Scottish Greens and the SNP

  • Meta AI spending plans cause share price slump

    The firm said expenses would be higher this year as it spends heavily on artificial intelligence.