Teen ‘fought for her life’ when she was killed in 1975, cops say. Now two are arrested

Mike Stunson
·2 min read

A cold case investigation that spanned nearly a half-century has led to the arrests of two men accused of killing a 17-year-old girl, Indiana cops say.

Indiana State Police announced the arrests on Tuesday, Feb. 7, of Fred Bandy Jr. and John Wayne Lehman, both 67. They are charged with murder in the death of Laurel Jean Mitchell, whose body was found in North Webster Lake in Kosciusko County on Aug. 7, 1975.

Kosciusko County is in northern Indiana about 45 miles west of Fort Wayne.

The discovery of Mitchell’s body came a day after she did not arrive home from her job at Epworth Forest Church Camp in Kosciusko County, troopers said.

“Her cause of death was listed as drowning, and the autopsy report showed signs that she had fought for her life,” Indiana State Police said in a news release.

Investigators spent hundreds of hours on the case, but it became cold until recent DNA evidence corroborated various testimonies.

Mitchell’s clothing was submitted to an Indiana State Police laboratory for DNA testing in 2019, according to Ink Free News. Samples on her clothing matched DNA of Bandy, the online publication reported, citing an affidavit.

Bandy and Lehman had already been identified as potential suspects. In 2019, a man spoke to a Noble County Sheriff’s Department detective and said Bandy and Lehman had admitted to him at a party that they killed Mitchell together, WPTA reported.

Lehman also admitted he was involved in the crime to a woman he dated in 1975, the woman told investigators in 2013, according to WANE.

“Investigators believe Bandy and Lehman grabbed her, put her in Bandy’s 1971 Oldsmobile and took her to the Mallard Roost public access site on County Road 600 N in Noble County where they drowned her,” WANE reported.

Bandy and Lehman were arrested Monday, Feb. 6, and are being held in the Noble County Jail without bond, state police said.

“Science finally gave us the evidence we needed,” Indiana State Police Capt. Kevin Smith said.

Vietnam War vet was shot, thrown in Michigan river in 1973. He’s now been identified

Slaying of Florida woman went unsolved for 36 years. A Mississippi man is now charged

Dead man linked to two sexual assaults and killings decades ago, Nevada cops say

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • Analysis-Bankers lose hope of London IPO revival for another year

    Banks have mostly given up hope this year will bring a long-awaited recovery in UK IPOs, as stock exchanges within the European Union and Switzerland have so far proved more tempting, senior bankers told Reuters. London, which was Europe's most popular listing venue in the boom of 2021, has attracted only 2% of all European IPO volumes since January, with Zurich and Frankfurt the busiest venues, Dealogic data showed. Part of the reason is the sluggishness of Britain's economic recovery and a perception its stock market is undervalued.

  • Here’s Why Cooper Investors Sold Danaher Corporation (DHR)

    Cooper Investors, an investment management firm, released its “Cooper Investors Global Equities Fund” first quarter 2024 investor letter. A copy of the letter can be downloaded here. The fund returned 7.4% in the first quarter, compared to a 9.4% return for the benchmark MSCI ACWI. The market rally, which started in late October 2023, has […]

  • How to avoid inheritance tax

    Inheritance tax is often called Britain’s most hated charge, but until recently it was only the very wealthy who had to pay it.

  • UN rights chief 'horrified' by mass grave reports at Gaza hospitals

    U.N. rights chief Volker Turk said on Tuesday that he was "horrified" by the destruction of the Nasser and Al Shifa medical facilities in Gaza and reports of mass graves containing hundreds of bodies there, according to a spokesperson. Palestinian authorities reported finding bodies in mass graves at a hospital in Khan Younis this week after it was abandoned by Israeli troops. Bodies were also reported at the Al Shifa site following an Israeli special forces operation.

  • Euro zone bond yields steady after mixed PMI data

    Eurozone government bond yields were steady on Tuesday as traders digested mixed Purchasing Managers' Index data from the euro area, which did not offer any new hints on how fast the European Central Bank could lower borrowing costs. Overall business activity in the euro zone expanded at its fastest pace in nearly a year, HCOB's preliminary composite PMI survey showed, propelled by a recovery in the bloc's dominant services sector. Germany's 10-year bond yield, the benchmark for the euro zone bloc, was last little changed at 2.49%.

  • World must come together to tackle plastic pollution, says chair of UN talks

    Ecuadorian ambassador to the UK is hopeful impasse can be overcome at treaty negotiations in Ottawa

  • Storm Brings Heavy Rain and Power Outages to Honduras

    A storm brought heavy rain, strong wind, and power outages to Tegucigalpa, the capital of Honduras, on April 22, local news reported.Winds from the Caribbean and the Pacific brought scattered rain and storms to several regions of the country, the Secretariat of Risk and Contingency Management said.Footage released by the National Police of Honduras shows a car driving along a flooded street in Tegucigalpa. Credit: National Police of Honduras via Storyful

  • European parliament worker arrested on suspicion of spying for China

    German police have arrested an employee of the far-Right Alternative for Germany party (AfD) on suspicion of spying for China, in the latest espionage case to hit Germany.

  • Karen, 5-Year-Old Ostrich, Dies At Topeka Zoo After Swallowing Keys

    “She was not just an animal; she was a beloved member of our community," the interim director of the zoo said.

  • May 2024 dates for benefits and pensions after cost of living payments

    April saw increases to benefits and the state pension

  • What are Tim Tams and where can I buy them? The iconic Aussie treat, explained

    You can order Tim Tams straight to your door through Deliveroo

  • Olympic gold medalist Allisha Gray hopes to be part of US 3x3 team in Paris Games

    SPRINGFIELD, Mass. (AP) — Allisha Gray is glad to be back playing 3x3 for USA Basketball with an eye towards being a member of the team at the Paris Olympics this summer. She's the only player returning from the foursome that took home the gold at the Tokyo Games three years ago. That was the inaugural appearance of the sport at the Olympics. “To be the first team to do it and it being the first time in the Olympics, it was amazing," Gray said. “It's great to be back and get back into the groove

  • Baltimore accuses firms behind Dali ship that downed Francis Scott Key Bridge of negligence

    The city of Baltimore is blaming the the owner and manager of a merchant vessel that crashed into the Francis Scott Key Bridge late last month of negligence.

  • UPDATE 1-UN rights chief 'horrified' by mass grave reports at Gaza hospitals

    U.N. rights chief Volker Turk said on Tuesday that he was "horrified" by the destruction of the Nasser and Al Shifa medical facilities in Gaza and reports of mass graves containing hundreds of bodies there, according to a spokesperson. Palestinian authorities reported finding bodies in mass graves at a hospital in Khan Younis this week after it was abandoned by Israeli troops. Bodies were also reported at the Al Shifa site following an Israeli special forces operation.

  • Hometown pride: Meet the NFL Draft hopefuls with North Carolina, South Carolina ties

    The 2024 NFL Draft begins Thursday and runs through Saturday.

  • British banking has become a stagnant backwater – and it’s painfully obvious why

    Should we be relieved or scared? More than a decade after the fallout from the financial crisis started to settle, during which time the UK’s lenders have broadly kept their heads down and their noses clean, the banking sector is dangerously close to becoming interesting again.

  • EastEnders - huge twist in Nadine and Jay baby story

    EastEnders has revealed a huge twist in Nadine Keller's baby story.

  • Mets’ Jose Butto and Francisco Alvarez gaining confidence speaking English: ‘You feel like, wow, this is different’

    SAN FRANCISCO — José Buttó started learning English during his first season in the minor leagues, with the Mets setting up their prospects in the Dominican Summer League with English classes. Still, it would be a little while before the Venezuelan right-hander would need to use any of the phrases and words he was learning. Once he got to Florida to play in Port St. Lucie, he wasn’t quite ready ...

  • Nicole Kidman honoured with AFI Life Achievement Award

    The Big Little Lies star will be the first Australian to receive the American Film Institute's Life Achievement Award. Kidman told Stellar magazine that she was grateful to join previous female recipients Lillian Gish, Bette Davis, Meryl Streep, Jane Fonda and Barbara Streisand. Awarded by the AFI Board of Trustees, the Institute’s prize is among the film world’s most coveted gongs. Male counterparts include George Clooney, Robert de Niro and Al Pacino. Nicole will be the 49th recipient of the AFI Life Achievement Award, which was first handed out in 1973.

  • West Columbia wants to improve its welcome mat along the river. Here’s what $2M+ could do

    The desirable Congaree River has been an anchor for much of the lively development just over the bridge from downtown Columbia in recent years. Now, more improvements to this area could be on tap.