Prosecutors to seek death penalty against suspect in Land Park slaying of Kate Tibbitts

Sam Stanton
·2 min read

Sacramento prosecutors have decided to seek a death penalty prosecution against Troy Davis, the parolee accused of breaking into a Land Park home in September and sexually assaulting and killing the homeowner, 61-year-old Kate Tibbitts.

Davis, 52, is being held without bail in the Sacramento County Main Jail on charges that include murder, rape, arson, burglary and intentional maiming of animals, counts that stem from Davis allegedly killing Tibbitts’ two dogs, Molly and Jenny, and setting fire to the 11th Avenue home.

When Davis was arrested in September following the slaying, prosecutors filed a special circumstance alleging he killed Tibbitts in the process of a burglary, and this month Sacramento County District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert’s office filed a “notice of intent to seek the death penalty” if he is convicted, according to court records.

Such decisions are rare in Sacramento, but have been made in cases involving particularly heinous crimes, including the successful death penalty prosecution of Luis Bracamontes after he killed a Sacramento County sheriff’s deputy and a Placer County sheriff’s detective during a 2014 rampage.

California Gov. Gavin Newsom has suspended use of the death penalty, but prosecutors continue to pursue capital punishment cases in the event that his decision is overturned by a future administration.

Mary Kate Tibbitts, 61, who was killed along with her two dogs inside her Land Park home on Friday, Sept. 3, 2021, is seen in an undated photo.
Mary Kate Tibbitts, 61, who was killed along with her two dogs inside her Land Park home on Friday, Sept. 3, 2021, is seen in an undated photo.

The Tibbitts slaying sparked widespread outrage, partly because law enforcement officials say Davis should have been in custody at the time of the slaying.

Davis was charged June 22 in a vehicle theft case and arrested but then released before appearing before a judge, court records say. Court records give no explanation for his release, which came despite the fact that he had a criminal history of two felony strikes.

Davis has a criminal history in Sacramento and Santa Cruz counties dating back to 2013 that includes charges of resisting an officer, battery on an officer, possession of methamphetamine, threatening an officer, misdemeanor sexual battery and assault and battery.

After his release from the Sacramento jail in June, Davis disappeared until his arrest in September following Tibbitts’ slaying.

His next appearance in Sacramento Superior Court is scheduled for June 10.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • Why you should buy stocks ahead of next week's inflation report

    Fundstrat's bullish short-term outlook is supported by declines in volatility, the US dollar, and long-term interest rates.

  • Hawaii officials outline efforts to prevent another devastating wildfire ahead of a dry season

    As Maui continues to recover from the deadliest U.S. wildfire in more than a century, Hawaii officials are looking at preventing another similar disaster as the state heads into what is expected to be a dry, fire-prone season, Gov. Josh Green said Friday in proclaiming Wildfire Mitigation and Risk Reduction Preparedness Month. The Aug. 8, 2023, wildfire destroyed much of the town of Lahaina and killed 101 people. Climate change has been boosting drought in Hawaii, drying the archipelago’s vegetation and increasing the risks of destructive blazes.

  • WABC Radio suspends Rudy Giuliani for flouting ban on discussing discredited election claims

    NEW YORK (AP) — Rudy Giuliani responded Friday to a report he's been suspended from WABC Radio — and had his daily show canceled — over his violation of a ban on discussing discredited 2020 election claims, saying the station's ban is overly broad and “a clear violation of free speech.” Giuliani issued a statement saying he had heard of WABC Radio owner John Catsimatidis' decision through “a leak” to The New York Times. Giuliani “left me no option,” Catsimatidis told the Times, saying that the f

  • High-roller swears he was drugged at Vegas blackjack table, offers $1 million for proof

    A Southern California real estate developer bought 14 billboards in Vegas offering a $1 million reward for info on who drugged him at a casino in 2021

  • Woman pulled from Sacramento house fire

    One person was pulled from a burning house on Friday, according to the Sacramento Fire Department.

  • New storms batter south Brazil, already reeling from deadly floods

    The state of Rio Grande do Sul was once again experiencing storms on Friday and the rainfall in the river basins could further aggravate the flooding that has already left many dead. More than 240,000 people have been displaced, and much of the region has been isolated by the floodwaters. (AP Video: Lucas Dumphreys)

  • ‘Stunning’ Northern Lights spotted across the UK

    The Aurora Borealis has been spotted in Whitley Bay on the north east coast, Essex, Cambridgeshire and Wokingham in Berkshire.

  • Wind storm expected to exacerbate fires near Fort Nelson, B.C.

    Two fires from 2023 have reignited in northeastern B.C., leading to an evacuation alert and the deployment of crews to the area.The Nogah Creek and Patry Creek wildfires, both near Fort Nelson, about 550 kilometres north of Prince George, went underground for the winter. They became what's known as sleeper fires — or more menacingly, zombie fires.This spring, they both reignited after the snow melted and the ground thawed, explained Pedro Roldan-Delgado, an information officer for the B.C. Wildf

  • U.S. punches ticket to Para hockey's gold-medal game

    CALGARY — The United States will be playing for gold Sunday at the World Para Ice Hockey Championship at WinSport Arena. The team, which advanced to its ninth straight gold-medal game with a 3-1 win over Czechia in Friday's semifinal, will either face Canada or China, who are squaring off in Friday's second semifinal. Malik Jones of the U.S. national team, scored the go-ahead goal with 7:01 remaining in the game. “It was a challenging environment for us today, we struggled to finish a few chance

  • Prison phone calls, more interrogation tapes highlight day 4 of Jaylin Brazier murder trial

    During Friday's witness testimony in Jaylin Brazier's murder trial in the death of Zion Foster, the prosecution played recorded phone conversations between Brazier and his ex-fiance, Katrina Smith, while he was incarcerated.

  • Arrest made after school bus taken in New Mexico

    Arrest made after school bus taken in New Mexico

  • Eurovision: Ireland’s Bambie Thug ‘cried’ when Israel made it to the final

    The organisers behind Eurovision have repeatedly rejected calls to ban Israel from the contest amid its ongoing war on Gaza

  • James Simons, mathematician, philanthropist and hedge fund founder, has died

    James “Jim” Simons, a renowned mathematician and pioneering investor who built a fortune on Wall Street and then became one of the nation's biggest philanthropists, has died at age 86. The charitable foundation that Simons co-founded with his wife, Marilyn, announced that Simons died Friday in New York. No cause of death was given. “Jim was an exceptional leader who did transformative work in mathematics and developed a world-leading investment company,” Simons Foundation President David Spergel

  • 1 of 3 teens charged with killing a Colorado woman while throwing rocks at cars pleads guilty

    One of three teens who was charged with killing a 20-year-old woman while throwing large rocks at passing cars in Colorado pleaded guilty on Friday to reduced charges under a plea agreement, prosecutors said. The deal reached with Zachary Kwak, 19, requires him to cooperate in the prosecution of the two other teens still being prosecuted on first-degree murder charges in the death of Alexa Bartell. Karol-Chik and Koenig have both pleaded not guilty.

  • The US may be 'sleepwalking' into a recession as cracks form in the labor market, top economist says

    Several financial models are already showing the US economy is on its way to a hard-landing, according to top economist David Rosenberg.

  • Stevie Wonder says Drake-Kendrick beef is a ‘distraction’ from real wars

    Legendary musician raised the subject of ongoing wars and homelessness when asked about the feuding rappers

  • Driver fell asleep before crash that killed 3 workers, PSP says

    Pennsylvania State Police say a box truck driver who hit and killed three workers along I-83 in York County last month fell asleep at the wheel.

  • 1 person pulled from Sacramento house fire

    One person was pulled from a burning house on Friday, according to the Sacramento Fire Department.

  • YRT ridership up 36 per cent, nearing pre-pandemic levels

    The amount of people riding York Region Transit (YRT) has almost returned to the pre-pandemic numbers. In a recent meeting, York Region council announced in its 2023 Transit System Performance Report that ridership last year reached 21.1 million, a staggering 36.6 per cent increase over 2022 ridership. Transit numbers in the region prior to COVID-19 reached 22.3 million in 2019, but two years later only 9.4 million had used the service. Those ridership numbers jumped to 15.5 million in 2022 and

  • Jalen Brunson starts for New York Knicks despite injured right foot

    INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — New York Knicks guard Jalen Brunson started Game 3 against the Indiana Pacers on Friday night despite having a sore right foot. The All-Star is averaging a league-high 35.6 points in the postseason, leading the Knicks to a 2-0 lead in the Eastern Conference semifinals. Brunson was injured late in the first quarter Wednesday night but returned in the second half and helped the Knicks rally for a 130-122 victory. Brunson is irreplaceable for the severely short-handed Knicks. He