Miami percussionist Jackson Strong says he doesn’t think playing live music is a crime.
So when he was approached by police at South Pointe Park in Miami Beach last month after performing with his band, he said he refused to show his ID when asked. That led to him getting handcuffed and removed from the park, according to a video of the June 12 encounter that Strong posted on his Instagram.
Strong said he was not arrested but fined $150 for performing at the park without a permit.
Strong, a 38-year-old mindset coach and member of the local rock band Lotus Collective, is now hoping to convince Miami Beach commissioners to reform city laws requiring a permit to perform music in South Beach’s most popular public areas.
A petition created as part of the effort has gathered over 600 signatures. Supporters called into a recent City Commission meeting to demand reform. And it has received attention from Beach commissioners interested in discussing the issue.
“We deserve to have our place in the world and not be stifled by an outdated government that is ruining the core of what Miami is,” Strong said.
In most of Miami Beach, playing live music in public is allowed without a permit. The only restrictions are in South Beach, where a local law requires performers or street vendors to apply for permits through a government lottery. There are 31 permits available via quarterly lottery to perform at one of 31 designated performance or vending areas south of 24th Street, such as Lincoln Road and Ocean Drive.
South Pointe Park isn’t a designated area, so street performances are outright banned there.
Michael Cantalupo, a Miami Beach resident and filmmaker who created the petition, said the current law restricts live music in exactly the part of the city where musicians would want to perform. South Beach is a world-famous tourist destination known for its nightlife and entertainment scene.
Cantalupo, who also plays percussion, said he believes the law is unconstitutional and is lobbying local leaders to change it. He proposes allowing unpermitted performances in city parks at certain hours, replacing the lottery with an on-demand system and increasing the cap on how many permits are issued. He also wants to streamline the application process to allow for quicker approval of permits.
“The city is worried about somebody basically just playing their stereo very loud with music with very hateful lyrics and scaring the public,” he said. “That’s still happening anyway.”
“We’re looking for that space to be able to do it,” he said. “So we’ve turned to parks.”
Miami Beach Commissioner Alex Fernandez, who has met with Cantalupo, said he agrees the current law goes too far. He said the law was intended to protect residents’ quality of life from “loud obnoxious amplified music,” but he doesn’t see anything wrong with live music at a park.
“Let’s restrict the bad stuff but let’s allow the right positive activity to move forward,” he said.
Fernandez did not provide details on how he would differentiate between certain types of musical performances. He said he wants to discuss the issue at a future city committee meeting.
Fernandez said he is still studying the issue but would generally support allowing unpermitted live music at public parks at certain hours with criteria on crowd size and noise levels, and streamlining the permit process.
“We can’t regulate so much that we take away from their quality of life,” he said.