The moment ‘My Unorthodox Life’ star Julia Haart knew divorce was her 'only option'

Erin Jensen, USA TODAY
·5 min read

Julia Haart burst onto the reality TV scene last year as one bad mother in platform heels on Netflix's “My Unorthodox Life.”

At 42, she left her ultra-Orthodox Jewish community in Monsey, New York – about 36 miles north of New York City – with money saved selling life insurance and annuities, unbeknownst to her first husband, Yosef Hendler.

“It has nothing to do with Judaism or religion. This has to do with fundamentalism,” Haart said in the Netflix series’ July 2021 premiere of why the mother of four fled. “In our community, a woman basically has one purpose: to follow her husband and to be a baby-making machine.”

It appeared that Haart had carved out the perfect life as CEO of Elite World Group (a model management company) and wife of Silvio Scaglia, a wealthy businessman who acquired EWG in 2011. “You’re my life,” he told her in the series opener. “I will not be alive without you.”

The 50 best TV shows to watch on Netflix in November: 'The Crown' makes a royal return

'Texas Killing Fields': Relentless dad Tim Miller wants Clyde Hedrick's 'name out there'

Viewers will find a very different reality for Haart and her children – Batsheva Haart, 29; Shlomo Haart, 27; Miriam Haart, 22; and Aron Hendler, 16 – in Season 2 (now streaming), taped early this year. Batsheva navigates singledom, Miriam has a new relationship and Haart gets divorced, again. Cameras captured Scaglia firing Haart in February after the two decided to divorce and after 2½ years of marriage. He accused her of misappropriating funds in a war that played out in the tabloids.

“There were so many things happening every day that all we could do is just hold on and just move forward,” Haart, 51, says. “There was no time to plan things or organize anything. Every day was something else crazy, and we just had to survive through it.”

The weight Scaglia’s accusations carried – which Haart denies – reminded her of the powerlessness she felt in Monsey. “It felt like again, I was in a position where (a) man (was) controlling my life and ruining me and destroying everything that I was.”

Gaslighting is the 2022 word of the year. Here's what it is and how to address it.

I am nervous before my wedding day. Is it normal or should I bail?

The former couple, who exchanged vows in June 2019, are not yet divorced. Haart says she is also appealing a Delaware court’s May ruling that she is not an equal partner in EWG.

A post-trial memorandum says that "despite the appearance of an equal partnership, the evidence reveals that Haart never owned an equal stake" in the parent company of EWG. "Haart has failed to meet her burden of proving" she does.

Haart says the pair split because of the way Scaglia treated her children. She realized “divorce is the only option” when her youngest, Aron, was upset that his stepfather had ignored him during his stay at the family's Tribeca penthouse.

In the Season 2 premiere, Scaglia summarizes his marital woes to Haart: "My problem is that your life is ruled by your children, and I don't want my life to be (ruled) by your children because I have different approaches to life."

Aron “just didn't get it,” says Haart. “He's like, ‘Did I do something? Is he angry at me?’ And it broke my heart. I couldn't watch that happen." She realized her "wishful thinking that things are gonna change" and that Scaglia would "fall in love with" her children would never be a reality. "That is what forced me to wake up and say, ‘Julia, this man is not changing. And if you love your children, this has to stop.’”

Why believe convicted liar Casey Anthony? Documentary director addresses 'understandable' outrage

Haart realized when it comes to relationships, she hadn’t entirely shed her Monsey mindset. Miriam says she witnessed her mother alter her voice and be subservient to Scaglia.

“This whole situation has forced me to acknowledge that although I'm a tough cookie at work, and I had eradicated the idea in my head from my old world that I'm somehow incapable of working, I realized that in my personal life I was still the man-pleaser,” Haart says. “I had been brought up (believing) my entire purpose was to be subservient and obedient to a man. It was his needs and concerns that were my sole focus if I wanted to be a righteous woman.”

Even recently, while browsing dating apps, she found herself reconsidering men she wasn’t interested in once she saw they’d liked her profile.

Review: Tim Burton turns 'Wednesday' Addams into a gothy 'Buffy' for Netflix

'The Crown' Season 5 fact check: Historian explains what really happened with Diana and Charles

“Because in my head, if a man says yes, you say yes,” Haart explains. “In personal relationships, I don't say no. I am still indoctrinated and brainwashed to think that my purpose in life is to please the man in my relationship. And I'm going to do everything I can to fix that incorrect concept and to recognize that I have equal value to whatever man I'm with.”

That includes going to therapy, reading books, and attending a class that helps its students break their people-pleasing habits.

“Someone is going to teach me the skills that I need to value myself in a personal relationship. That's awesome!" she says. "I'm going to work on it because hey, I'm a work in progress, and I allowed myself to get back into that subservient role. And I will never do that again.”

What's real in 'Welcome to Chippendales': From tearaway pants to tragic Playmate Dorothy Stratten

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Julia Haart, 'My Unorthodox Life' star, knew divorce was 'only option'

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • The 30 best Walmart deals to shop this weekend — save up to 80% on outdoor gear, gardening supplies, tech and more

    Some major deals on board: a Mother's Day-ready digital picture frame for $30 off, a cordless 6-in-1 stick vac for just $90, and a Chromebook laptop for under $150.

  • Togo lawmakers give final approval to new constitution amid opposition fears

    Togo lawmakers on Friday gave final approval to a constitutional reform that switches to a parliamentary system that triggered criticism from opposition parties who say it allows President Faure Gnassingbe to keep a grip on power. The approval came days before April 29 legislative elections in Togo, where the opposition dismissed the reform as a "constitutional coup" for creating a new prime minister-style post they say will allow the Togolese leader to avoid term limits to stay in office.Togo's

  • How Rich Are Biden, Trump and These Other Potential 2024 Presidential Candidates?

    With the 2024 presidential election months away, on November 5, 2024, candidates have been dropping out of the race until just a handful of hopefuls remain. The U.S. president earns $400,000 a year,...

  • Prosecutor won't bring charges against Wisconsin lawmaker over fundraising scheme

    A Wisconsin prosecutor said Friday that she won't bring charges against a Republican lawmaker accused of trying to evade state campaign finance laws in order to unseat the powerful speaker of the Assembly. Waukesha County District Attorney Susan Opper said she would not be filing felony charges against Rep. Janel Brandtjen as was recommended by the bipartisan Wisconsin Ethics Commission.

  • Chad air force chief orders US to halt activities at army base, letter shows

    Chad has so far not followed the steps of juntas in Burkina Faso, Mali and Niger in ending military collaborations with France and other traditional Western allies while they strengthen ties with Russia instead. In the letter dated April 4 to Chad's minister of armed forces, Air Force Chief of Staff Idriss Amine Ahmed said he had told the U.S. defence attache to halt U.S. activities at the Adji Kossei Air Base after “Americans” had failed to provide documents justifying their presence there.

  • 'Sullivan's Crossing' star Chad Michael Murray reveals why Nova Scotia set reminds him of 'One Tree Hill'

    Chad Michael Murray revealed there's something special about CTV's Sullivan's Crossing that he hasn't felt since Once Tree Hill.

  • I'm a home product tester — and I did a double-take when I saw these chic patio chairs on sale for $37 each

    Outdoor furniture can be ridiculously expensive, but this 'sturdy and beautiful' rattan set won't break the bank.

  • Venue opens doors again more than a year after fatal crush

    The O2 Brixton Academy had heavy security for the reopening.

  • Dow Jones Rises After Israel Strike But Nvidia, SMCI Flash Sell Signals; Tesla Earnings Loom While Bitcoin's Fourth Halving Arrives

    The Dow Jones rose Friday on Friday. Netflix plunged after earnings. Nvidia and SMCI triggered sell signals while bitcoin's halving looms.

  • Super Micro Stock Plunges 23% On Lack Of Preliminary Results. It's A Big Sell Signal.

    Super Micro stock fell hard after the data-center computer specialist didn't announce preliminary results for its fiscal Q3.

  • Late-blooming, mustached goalie Charlie Lindgren carries the Washington Capitals into the playoffs

    ARLINGTON, Va. (AP) — Alex Ovechkin scored a lot of goals down the stretch for the Washington Capitals, yet he is not the biggest reason they made the playoffs. That would be undrafted, unheralded, late-blooming, mustached goaltender Charlie Lindgren, who emerged as the starter and carried the Capitals the second half of the season. No one in the NHL faced more shots or made more saves over the past three months since supplanting Darcy Kuemper for the No. 1 job. Lindgren's play in net has made h

  • Prayer ban head criticises Braverman for using school as ‘political football’

    The Conservative MP co-founded the school alongside current headteacher Katherine Birbalsingh.

  • Man sets himself on fire outside Trump trial courthouse in New York

    Florida resident in critical condition in hospital after images of incident carried live on television

  • US House advances $95 bln package for Ukraine

    STORY: The U.S. House of Representatives on Friday moved ahead with a $95 billion legislative package providing aid to Ukraine and Israel in a broad bipartisan vote, overcoming hardline Republican opposition that had held it up for months.Friday's procedural vote passed with more support from Democrats than from Republicans, who hold a razor-thin majority in the chamber.The package is similar to one that passed the Democratic-controlled Senate in February. But the Republican Speaker of the House Mike Johnson, held off on it for months in the face of fierce opposition from a small but vocal segment of his own party."This was going to require substantial Democratic participation."House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries on Friday told reporters that his party had to step up and ensure support to U.S. allies Ukraine and Israel because of some lawmakers he called "pro-Putin Republicans.""And we had a choice: are we going to put people over politics. Because the political thing to do is always to let the extreme MAGA Republicans crash and burn. Because they have so many out-of-control members, they cannot govern on their own."Republican lawmakers such as Kentucky Representative Thomas Massie of the House Freedom Caucus objected to advancing the aid package."I'm concerned that the Speaker's cut a deal with the Democrats to fund foreign wars rather than to secure our border."Texas Republican Chip Roy demanded Speaker Johnson live up to a pledge to first get funding for the U.S. Southern Border."To that I say, amen, and where is that, Speaker Johnson?"Republican lawmaker Majorie Taylor Greene has already filed a motion to vacate Johnson's seat as speaker. Greene has not said whether she will pursue the motion, but on Wednesday predicted he would not remain in leadership for long.The House is expected to vote on the measure on Saturday, after which it will return to the Senate, and is expected to move from there to U.S. President Joe Biden's desk and be signed into law.

  • Opening statements set for Monday in Trump's hush money case after judge rejects latest bid to delay

    NEW YORK (AP) — A full jury of 12 people and six alternates was seated Friday in Donald Trump’s hush money case, setting the stage for opening statements next week in the first criminal trial of a former U.S. president. Hours later, an appeals court judge rejected a last-minute bid by the Republican to halt the trial over his claims that jury selection was unfairly rushed. The jury, which includes a software engineer, investment banker, English teacher and multiple lawyers, took final shape afte

  • Stolen tropical fish returned to Ottawa Valley restaurant

    Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) have found and returned tropical fish stolen from an Ottawa Valley restaurant last week.The fish were taken from the Beachburg Restaurant in an overnight break-in on April 11, OPP said. An undisclosed amount of cash was also stolen. The owner of the restaurant told CBC after the theft that she wasn't sure how many fish were taken from the restaurant's aquarium, but that there were "a lot of them" including clownfish.Police said the owner valued the fish at several

  • Outside of AI, chip sector is 'not all that great': Analyst

    Shares of Super Micro Computer (SMCI) fell sharply Friday after the company opted not to pre-announce its first-quarter results. This development comes as the semiconductor sector undergoes a sector-wide correction. Bernstein Managing Director and Senior Analyst Stacy Rasgon joins Market Domination to provide insights into this situation. Rasgon acknowledges that while the chip sector is undergoing a correction, "outside of AI" the industry has not been performing well. He notes that other segments of the sector, such as automotive, data centers, PCs, and smartphones, "are not all that great," which could be contributing to the sector-wide pressure, in addition to the disappointing earnings from major players. Rasgon shifts the focus to the question of "the pace of the recovery," noting that the stocks have held up "remarkably" despite the revisions, suggesting this is "a delayed reaction." For more expert insight and the latest market action, click here to watch this full episode of Market Domination. This post was written by Angel Smith

  • Taylor Swift’s ‘The Tortured Poets Department' is here. Is it poetry? This is what experts say

    NEW YORK (AP) — Taylor Swift has released her 11th studio album, “The Tortured Poets Department.” But just how poetic is it? Is it even possible to close read lyrics like poems, divorced from their source material? The Associated Press spoke to four experts to assess how Swift's latest album stacks up to poetry. IS TAYLOR SWIFT A POET? Allison Adair, a professor who teaches poetry and other literary forms at Boston College, says yes. “My personal opinion is that if someone writes poems and consi

  • The Latest | Appeals court judge rejects bid for temporary stay in Trump's hush money trial

    NEW YORK (AP) — A jury of 12 people and six alternates was seated on Friday in former President Donald Trump’s hush money criminal case. The completion of jury selection sets the stage for opening statements in the first-ever criminal trial of a former U.S. president to begin Monday, as well as weeks of testimony in a case charging Trump with falsifying business records to suppress stories about his sex life emerging in the final days of the 2016 election. The jury includes a sales professional,

  • This week’s Best Thing in Baseball: Andrew McCutchen hits 300th career HR

    Yahoo Sports national MLB insider Russell Dorsey’s Best Thing in Baseball this week is Andrew McCutchen’s 300th career homer in a 9-2 Pirates victory over the Phillies.