‘Will You Marry Her’: SC Asks Rape Accused, Twitter Slams Question

The Quint
·2 min read

The Chief Justice of India (CJI) SA Bobde on Monday, 1 March, asked a government employee if he would marry the woman who has accused him of repeatedly raping her.

The Supreme Court was hearing the bail request of Mohit Subhash Chavan, a technician with the Maharashtra State Electric Production Company, reported NDTV. He was accused of raping a schoolgirl and faces charges under the severe POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences) Act.

According to Bar and Bench, Bobde asked the petitioner, 'Will you marry her?', adding:

"“We are not forcing you to marry. Let us know if you will. Otherwise you will say we are forcing you to marry her.”" - CJI Bobde

Also Read: What is Rape Culture?

The counsel for the petitioner replied:

“I wanted to marry her. But she refused. Now, I cannot, as I am already married. Trial is going on, charges are yet to be framed.”

The court granted interim protection to the accused for four weeks and asked him to apply for regular bail.

WHAT HAPPENED

Chavan, the accused, reportedly used to follow the then 16-year-old girl on her way to school. The survivor is also a distant relative of the accused.

He allegedly raped the survivor after he tied her hands and legs, the first time. He repeated the crime 10-12 times, when the survivor was in class nine, reported Bar and Bench.

The survivor was stopped from filing a police complaint after the accused's mother promised that he would marry her. While some reports say she refused to marry him after turning 18, others maintain that he refused – prompting her to go to court.

Also Read: Why Rape Culture Won’t Stop With the Death Penalty

‘Supreme Court or Khap Panchayat’: Twitter Reacts to CJI’s Question

Social media users took to Twitter to express that ‘marrying the rapist’ does nothing but harm and is more of a ‘reward than punishment.’

(With inputs from NDTV, Bar and Bench.)

. Read more on Gender by The Quint.I’d Rather Miss Olympics than Take Vaccine: Sprinter Yohan Blake ‘Will You Marry Her’: SC Asks Rape Accused, Twitter Slams Question . Read more on Gender by The Quint.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • 2024 Hot Docs 'An Unfinished Journey': 4 women leaders who fled Afghanistan fighting against gender apartheid

    An Unfinished Journey part of the 2024 Hot Docs Festival documents four women who resettled in Canada After the 2021 Taliban take over in Afghanistan.

  • Ignace voting on potential nuclear waste facility

    IGNACE — Residents and property owners began voting just after midnight Friday on whether they support Ignace moving forward as a potential host community for a nuclear waste repository. Online and in-person, individuals aged 16 and over may cast a ballot on whether the township should “continue participating in the process.” A consulting firm will use the results as data for a report to Ignace council on the degree of “community willingness.” Laura Tanguay, a doctoral candidate in environmental

  • Caleb Williams Shows Off His Style at NFL Draft: ‘I Paint My Nails, I Wear Unique Things’

    The top overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft described his look for the big night as "subtle" and "classy"

  • Austin says Patriot missile system may not be 'silver bullet' for Ukraine's defense

    At a press conference on Friday, Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin responded to a question about Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky's desire for more Patriot missile systems to defend against Russia's invasion. Austin said that Ukraine needs other systems as well and cautioned against focusing on the Patriot missile system as a "silver bullet" for the country's defense.

  • Cap on plastic production may be too complicated for global treaty: Guilbeault

    OTTAWA — A global treaty to end plastic waste can be ambitious and successful without firm caps on plastic production, which are hard to design and harder to get agreement on, Canada's environment minister said Friday. Negotiators from 175 nations are in Ottawa trying to solidify some of the details of such a treaty, which is supposed to be finalized this fall in Korea. A cap on plastics is among the most contentious items on the table. Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault said there's a need

  • Animal groups are urging tourists not to visit Wyoming after a man hit a wolf then took it to a bar

    CHEYENNE, Wyo. (AP) — As Yellowstone National Park in Wyoming opens for the busy summer season, wildlife advocates are leading a call for a boycott of the conservative ranching state over laws that give people wide leeway to kill gray wolves with little oversight. The social media accounts of Wyoming's tourism agency are being flooded with comments urging people to steer clear of the Cowboy State amid accusations that a man struck a wolf with a snowmobile, taped its mouth shut and showed off the

  • Oregon State and Washington State face player exodus amid realignment

    Perhaps the biggest blow for Oregon State in recent weeks was the departure of running back Damien Martinez, who had previously pledged his loyalty to the Beavers. Twelve players from Washington State's men's basketball team that went to the NCAA Tournament this past season for the first time since 2008 have entered the portal.

  • Cash couriers who smuggled £100million out of UK in suitcases sentenced

    Gang used WhatApp group called ‘Sunshine and lollipops’ to co-ordinate money laundering between the UK and Dubai

  • Atikokan culvert replacement weeks away from completion

    ATIKOKAN – The Mercury Avenue culvert is almost fully repaired. The Town of Atikokan declared a state of emergency last May after a storm caused the culvert’s failure and washed out a 15-metre section of roadway. “This declaration empowers the municipality to take swift and decisive action to protect public safety and allocate the necessary resources to address the situation,” the announcement stated. Nearly one year later, the new culvert’s installation is all but completed and Mercury Avenue i

  • More Indigenous content among changes to Alberta's draft K-6 social studies curriculum

    The latest draft of Alberta's elementary school social studies curriculum is out, with revisions that integrate more Indigenous perspectives and a focus on critical thinking.The third iteration of kindergarten to Grade 6 social studies content comes after the province took the curriculum back to the drawing board in the wake of backlash over a 2021 draft, with critics saying it was age-inappropriate and culturally exclusive.The government subsequently did a new round of consultations with the pu

  • JPMorgan's Dimon hopes for soft landing for US economy but says stagflation is a possible scenario

    NEW YORK (AP) — JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon says he’s hopeful the Federal Reserve can bring down inflation without causing a recession but wouldn’t rule out more troubling possibilities, such as stagflation. In an interview with The Associated Press at a Chase branch opening in The Bronx, Dimon said he remained “cautious” about the U.S. economy and said inflation may be stickier for longer and that “stagflation is on the list of possible things” that could happen to the U.S. economy. “You sho

  • Hollyoaks teases Carter downfall ahead of dramatic week

    Hollyoaks teased a dramatic downfall for Carter Shepherd after he was exposed ahead of the village’s Pride Festival.

  • OJ Simpson’s official cause of death revealed

    The disgraced former NFL star previously revealed he had been diagnosed with an unspecified form of cancer last year

  • Blue envelopes: Arizona launching program to help keep autistic drivers safer

    Arizona is launching a 'blue envelope' program that is aimed at helping autistic drivers better navigate what to do when being contacted by an officer.

  • UPDATE 1-Google files motion for summary judgment in U.S. ad tech case

    Alphabet Inc's Google on Friday asked a federal court in Virginia to reject a U.S. government lawsuit accusing the advertising and search company of anticompetitive practices in the online advertising marketplace. The government, which filed the ad tech lawsuit in January 2023 along with eight states, accused the company of abusing its dominance of the digital advertising business and argued that it should be forced to sell its ad manager suite. Google’s online advertising network, which includes ad manager, brought in 12% of the company’s revenue in 2021.

  • Michael Bisping warns Islam Makhachev of ‘sniper’ Leon Edwards: ‘Be careful what you wish for’

    Michael Bisping advises UFC lightweight champion Islam Makhachev to focus on his division.

  • Cockroaches, meat residue and yellow slime: See latest Sacramento County health inspections

    Sacramento County conducts roughly 14,000 inspections of food facilities each year.

  • All about Jill Dando's former fiancé Alan Farthing and his royal connection

    The BBC documentary The Murder of Jill Dando delves into the death of the famous BBC broadcaster. But did you know her former fiancé Alan Farthing has a connection to the royal family?

  • Kia EV9 GT performance three-row SUV to be revealed next year

    Kia EV9 GT will be the high-performance version of the three-row electric SUV, and it will be shown next year with around 600 horsepower.

  • IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Benny Blanco opens up about falling for Selena Gomez

    The songwriter and record producer has revealed he realised he had feelings for the Lose You to Love Me singer during a recording session. The pair had known each other as friends and collaborators for nearly a decade before they started dating in June last year. In an interview with the Wall Street Journal published on Thursday, Benny admitted he "was the last one to know" he was in love with Selena. "It's crazy how your partner could just be sitting there the whole time,…”