Madonna was once told that "Like a Virgin" would not make her, but break her.
While appearing on The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon Wednesday, the Queen of Pop, 63, remembered the harsh words her then-manager Freddy DeMann had following her now-iconic performance of "Like a Virgin," at the very first MTV Video Music Awards in 1984.
Reflecting on the release of her sophomore album Like a Virgin that year, host Jimmy Fallon pointed out that music producer Nile Rodgers wanted her to drop "Material Girl" as the album's lead single, but "Like a Virgin" was used instead.
"I don't know why they chose 'Like A Virgin' because I thought it was quite controversial," Madonna told the host, 47. "It turned out that the controversial thing wasn't the song itself but my performance at the MTV Awards, the first MTV Awards."
She continued, "I walked down these very steep stairs… and I got to the bottom, and started dancing around, and my white stiletto pumps fell off," which caused her white wedding dress to flip up and expose her butt as she reached to grab the shoes.
At the time, showing that much skin was scandalous in itself, the star said.
Todd Owyoung/NBC via Getty
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
"Those were the days when you shouldn't show your butt to have a career," Madonna joked. "Now it's the opposite… I didn't even know my butt was showing!"
After the accident, when the performance wrapped, the pop legend said her manager told her backstage that her "career was over with."
"Wow," Fallon replied.
Courtest Everett Collection
But instead of derailing her career, the history-making performance of "Like a Virgin" catapulted Madonna to new heights as she pushed the limits for artistic expression on stage, though such audacity was unconventional at the time.
"Like a Virgin" became Madonna's first of 12 No. 1 hits on the Billboard Hot 100 and, in 2014, 30 years after the performance, MTV called Madonna's performance "one of the most important and most unforgettable VMA performances ever, if not one of the most iconic pop performances of all time."