Jury deliberating in trial over murder of college student Kristin Smart

MEREDITH DELISO and DEA ATHON
·2 min read

The jury is deliberating in the murder trial of the man accused of killing Kristin Smart, a California college student who disappeared in 1996 while walking home from a party.

Paul Flores, 45, who walked Smart from the party and previously was named the "prime suspect," was arrested and charged with her murder last year.

After 11 weeks of testimony, closing arguments wrapped late Tuesday afternoon and the jury is currently deliberating their verdict.

PHOTO: Paul Flores listens during the closing arguments in the Kristin Smart murder trial on Oct. 3, 2022 in Salinas, Calif. Flores is accused of the murder of Kristin Smart. (Laura Dickinson/The Tribune (of San Luis Obispo) via AP, Pool)
PHOTO: Paul Flores listens during the closing arguments in the Kristin Smart murder trial on Oct. 3, 2022 in Salinas, Calif. Flores is accused of the murder of Kristin Smart. (Laura Dickinson/The Tribune (of San Luis Obispo) via AP, Pool)

In his closing argument, defense attorney Robert Sanger told the jury, "there is no evidence of a murder so that's really the end of it."

"This case was not prosecuted all these years because there was no evidence and there's still no evidence," he said.

MORE: Kristin Smart case: Former classmate arrested in 1996 disappearance of Cal Poly student

The prosecutor, San Luis Obispo County Deputy District Attorney Chris Peuvrelle, tried to show a pattern of behavior by Flores that began with Smart. Two women, Sarah Doe and Rhonda Doe, testified during the trial that they were drugged and sexually assaulted by Flores in 2008 and 2011, respectively.

"Do you see a pattern here?" Peuvrelle asked the jury in his closing argument, calling Flores a "serial drugger and rapist."

Sanger argued there was no evidence that Smart was raped or that Flores attempted to rape her and jurors should not consider the testimony of Sarah Doe and Rhonda Doe.

PHOTO: Paul Flores listens during the closing arguments as Judge Jennifer O'keefe presides in the Kristin Smart murder trial on Oct. 3, 2022 in Salinas, Calif. Flores is accused of the murder of Kristin Smart. (Laura Dickinson/The Tribune (of San Luis Obispo) via AP, Pool)
PHOTO: Paul Flores listens during the closing arguments as Judge Jennifer O'keefe presides in the Kristin Smart murder trial on Oct. 3, 2022 in Salinas, Calif. Flores is accused of the murder of Kristin Smart. (Laura Dickinson/The Tribune (of San Luis Obispo) via AP, Pool)

In her instructions to the jurors, Judge Jennifer O'Keefe said they need to decide if they believe Flores drugged and raped Sarah Doe and Rhonda Doe. If the answer is yes, they can rely on their testimony; if the answer is no, they cannot use their testimony.

Flores' father, Ruben Flores, 81, was charged with being an accessory to the crime last year. Prosecutors say he helped hide Smart's body before moving it in 2020.

MORE: Kristin Smart's parents sue murder suspect's father for allegedly moving her body

The two men are being tried at the same time, with separate juries hearing the case together. After hearing closing arguments Wednesday, the jury is now deliberating in the Ruben Flores' trial.

Once a verdict is reached by one jury, it will be sealed until the other jury reaches their verdict.

PHOTO: Photo released by the FBI shows Kristin Smart, the California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo student who disappeared in 1996. Smart was last seen in May 1996, while returning to her dorm after an off-campus party. (AP)
PHOTO: Photo released by the FBI shows Kristin Smart, the California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo student who disappeared in 1996. Smart was last seen in May 1996, while returning to her dorm after an off-campus party. (AP)

A judge earlier this year ordered that the Flores trials be moved out of San Luis Obispo County more than 100 miles away -- north to Monterey County -- to ensure fair legal proceedings.

Both Paul and Ruben Flores have pleaded not guilty to their charges.

Smart, a 19-year-old freshman at California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, disappeared in the early hours of May 25, 1996, after a party near school. Her body has never been found.

Jury deliberating in trial over murder of college student Kristin Smart originally appeared on abcnews.go.com

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest Stories

  • U.S. FAA to probe baseball coach in cockpit during a flight from Denver to Toronto

    LOS ANGELES — Authorities in the United States are investigating after a video surfaced on social media of a hitting coach for the Colorado Rockies sitting in the cockpit of an aircraft "at cruise altitude," while bound for Toronto. A statement from the Federal Aviation Administration says an investigation is underway but it will not comment further while the process is ongoing. The comments come after a post on social media platform X showed a video allegedly taken from the Instagram account of

  • Dave & Buster’s hiring for over 180 roles in Port St. Lucie

    Dave & Buster’s hiring for over 180 roles in Port St. Lucie

  • Jameson Taillon comes off the injured list and pitches Cubs to 8-3 win, dropping Marlins to 4-16

    CHICAGO (AP) — Jameson Taillon allowed one run over five innings in his first start this season after recovering from a strained back, and the Chicago Cubs beat the Miami Marlins 8-3 on Friday. Nico Hoerner doubled twice for the Cubs, who have won five of six. Miami fell to an NL-worst 4-16. Taillon (1-0), in the second season of a $68 million, four-year contract, did not pitch in any spring training games, then made a pair of minor league rehab outings on April 7 and 12. The 32-year-old right-h

  • Here’s how Phish is using the Sphere's technology to give fans something completely different

    LAS VEGAS (AP) — Phish opened its four-night stay at the Sphere Thursday with a four-hour show that used the advanced technology in the $2.3 billion arena to deliver a show that even the band's most ardent fans have never experienced before. “We came in really wanting to do a show that was a great Phish show,” said Abigail Rosen Holmes, who is running the visual show. She said the band and its creative team wanted to mix the Sphere’s technical capabilities and consider “what can we do for Phish

  • Mama Bear Saves Cub After Plummet Into River

    A mama bear sprang into action to rescue her cub after it fell from a railway bridge into a river in Plymouth, Connecticut, footage posted on April 17 shows.Tyler Nolan and his family captured this dramatic video that shows the bears atop a railway bridge over the Pequabuck River in the village of Terryville.“While walking our dog in a field nearby my house, we noticed the dog acting erratically,” Nolan told Storyful.“After noticing this behavior change, we saw a mama bear. To be safe, we returned to the house and grabbed the car to get a better view from a safer spot. When we returned, we noticed the mama bear had a cub,” he said.The adult bear can be seen interacting with her cub before the baby drops off the bridge into the river below.“We kept recording. You can hear the mama bear in distress, making grunting sounds and worried. It finally jumped into the river. It got the cub, and retreated back on to the shore.”Nolan said the pair seemed unharmed and that they disappeared into the woods shortly after. Credit: Tyler Nolan via Storyful

  • N.S. Justice Minister Brad Johns resigns from cabinet

    Nova Scotia Justice Minister Brad Johns has resigned from cabinet.Premier Tim Houston made the announcement in a news release sent Friday evening.The resignation comes a day after Johns's comments on domestic violence in Nova Scotia.The minister said he doesn't believe it's an epidemic — a position that's contrary to the Nova Scotia Mass Casualty Commissions's final report.Thursday and Friday marked the four-year anniversary of the Nova Scotia mass shooting, a tragedy that resulted in the deaths

  • Remembering Dave Sanders | Columbine 25 years

    In honor of the victims of Columbine on the occasion of 25 years since the tragedy, these are the inscriptions on each plaque provided by the Columbine Memorial Foundation. This is Dave Sanders’ tribute.

  • Temple vandalism suspect turns himself in

    Investigators said Kevin O'Leary, 31, faces a charge of hate-motivated criminal mischief.

  • 'I hope everyone turns into a Swiftie' WNY Record stores prepare for National Record Store Day

    The release date of Taylor Swift's newest album Tortured Poets Department and National Record Store Day coincided, meaning more people are coming into record stores across the country.

  • Steve Yzerman, Derek Lalonde express "good, but not good enough" review of 2023-24 season

    Steve Yzerman, Derek Lalonde express "good, but not good enough" review of 2023-24 season

  • Lando Norris takes F1 Chinese Grand Prix sprint pole from Hamilton

    McLaren's Lando Norris had his fastest lap deleted and reinstated as he seized pole position for the Chinese Grand Prix sprint race at the end of a wet and chaotic qualifying on Friday.

  • Remembering Daniel Mauser | Columbine 25 years

    In honor of the victims of Columbine on the occasion of 25 years since the tragedy, these are the inscriptions on each plaque provided by the Columbine Memorial Foundation. This is Daniel Mauser’s tribute.

  • Man who set himself on fire outside Trump trial identified as ‘researcher’ who posted conspiracy-laden manifesto online

    The NYPD identified the man as Maxwell Azzarello, 37, who is now in critical condition in Cornell burns unit. He has a long history of posting conspiracy theories and railing against the rich and powerful

  • Is the Israel-Iran conflict over?

    From the moment news broke that Iran had launched an unprecedented attack on Israel last weekend, fears spread that the strike could pull the global community into a widespread regional conflict. However, that didn't happen. Yahoo News explains how the U.S. and Israeli reaction to the Iranian attack unfolded and avoided the worst-case scenario — at least for now.

  • WNBA exhibition in Edmonton rescheduled to accommodate possible Oilers playoff game

    EDMONTON — The WNBA exhibition scheduled for next month at Edmonton's Rogers Place has been rescheduled to accommodate a potential Game 7 in the Oilers' first-round NHL playoff series against the Los Angeles Kings. The pre-season game between the Los Angeles Sparks and the Seattle Storm had originally been scheduled for Sunday, May 5. However, when the NHL released its playoff schedule, it had a potential deciding game in the series scheduled for the same day. The NBA says the WNBA game has been

  • Five high school students wounded in Maryland shooting

    Gunfire broke out at a park in Greenbelt, Maryland, where hundreds of high school students had gathered while skipping school on Friday, wounding five males aged 16 to 18, police said. One victim was in critical condition and the others were in stable condition, Greenbelt Police Chief Richard Bowers told a press conference. There have been 120 such mass shootings in the United States in the first 110 days of this year, when defined as an incident with four or more people shot or killed, not including the shooter, according to the Gun Violence Archive.

  • Chris Pratt draws ire for razing historic 1950 LA home for sprawling mansion

    Actor and wife Katherine Schwarzenegger dismantle 1950 Zimmerman house designed by architect Craig Ellwood

  • Calendar of chaos: How Trump’s trial dates and the 2024 election overlap

    Three criminal trials, one civil trial, and 50 primaries all within 11 months. How will Donald Trump manage a presidential campaign and his many legal trials in one year? Ariana Baio breaks it down

  • Taylor Swift’s The Tortured Poets Department – live updates: What critics and fans are saying

    Pop star shares message with fans from Instagram as fans celebrate new album release, with many noticing several lyrical references to The 1975’s Matty Healy along with her ex-boyfriend Joe Alwyn

  • Max Azzarello posted anti-establishment conspiracies online. He set himself on fire outside Trump’s trial moments later

    The man was later identified by the New York Police Department as 37-year-old Max Azzarello from St Augustine Florida