Fact check: Fake Time magazine cover compares Vladimir Putin to Adolf Hitler
The claim: A photo shows a Time magazine cover comparing Vladimir Putin to Adolf Hitler
In the early morning of Feb. 24, before Russia launched a large-scale military invasion of neighboring Ukraine, President Vladimir Putin claimed one of his aims was to “denazify” the country.
A few days later, a number of well-known figures shared a photo that seemed to show a Time magazine cover comparing Putin to the former leader of the Nazi Party.
“The Return of History: How Putin Shattered Europe's Dreams,” reads a title on the purported cover, shared in a Feb. 28 Facebook post from French actor Jean-Michel Tinivelli.
Several other prominent social media accounts also shared the image.
A Feb. 28 Instagram post from Ukraine's Ministry of Foreign Affairs received over 57,000 likes in less than 24 hours. The image was shared in dozens of other Facebook, Instagram and Twitter posts, including one from Argentinian journalist Luis Novaresio.
The only problem: It's not a real Time magazine cover. The image is altered.
Follow us on Facebook! Like our page to get updates throughout the day on our latest debunks
In an Instagram message to USA TODAY, Novaresio said he shared the image after a colleague posted it and that he didn't know it was fake.
USA TODAY reached out to the Ukrainian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Tinivelli for comment. The agency later edited its Instagram post to note the photo was a "fun illustration."
Recent Time cover shows Russian tank, not Putin
While the viral photo resembles a Time cover and uses the title from the magazine's most recent issue, it wasn’t created by anyone affiliated with the magazine.
Welsh graphic designer Patrick Mulder first posted the photo in a Feb. 26 tweet. The original image bears his name in the bottom-right corner, but the signature isn't visible in other posts of the image shared online.
Fact check roundup: What's true and what's false about the Russian invasion of Ukraine
In a statement tweeted Feb. 28, Mulder said he created the composite photo of Putin and Hitler the day Russia invaded Ukraine. He said he later made it into a Time cover lookalike because “the finished image was so powerful, I felt that it deserved to be framed in an equally powerful way."
The real cover photo for the most recent Time issue shows a group of soldiers riding in a Russian tank, not Putin. According to Time's website, documentary photographer Nanna Heitmann took the image in eastern Ukraine on the day of Russia's invasion.
TIME’s new cover: How Putin shattered Europe’s dreams https://t.co/jXsRFKrW8B pic.twitter.com/hDJs0ptJs0
— TIME (@TIME) February 25, 2022
USA TODAY has previously debunked numerous fake Time covers.
Our rating: Altered
Based on our research, we rate ALTERED a photo that claims to show a Time magazine cover comparing Putin to Hitler. A graphic designer created the photo of Putin and Hitler and edited it to appear as if it were a real Time cover. The magazine's most recent cover shows a Russian tank, not Putin.
Our fact-check sources:
Time magazine, Feb. 24, Tweet (archived)
Time magazine, Feb. 24, Putin Wants Revenge Not Just on Ukraine But on the U.S. and Its Allies
Patrick Mulder, Feb. 28, Tweet (archived)
Patrick Mulder, Feb. 26, Tweet (archived)
Luis Novaresio, Feb. 28, Instagram correspondence with USA TODAY
USA TODAY, Dec. 16, 2020, Fact check: Joe Biden, Kamala Harris – not China's Xi Jinping – are Time's 2020 Person of the Year
USA TODAY, Dec. 15, 2021, Fact check: Image claiming to show Musk and Maxwell as Time's Person of the Year is altered
Magnum Photos, accessed March 1, Nanna Heitmann
Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.
Our fact-check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Fact check: Vladimir Putin, Adolf Hitler not featured on Time cover