Advertisement

Despite troubled FIFA and autocratic Qatar, World Cup is proving itself a force for good. Really.

You do not have to look far to see soccer’s enormous impact and emotional tug on planet Earth.

Start, perhaps, with the fierce rivalry between Brazil and Argentina – among the citizenry of Bangladesh. Then move on to how support for the English Premier League, particularly Liverpool, developed in French-speaking Rwanda as a tiny refuge of joy during that nation’s genocidal civil war in the 1990s.

And finish off by looking at the mind-boggling audiences for the sport’s main event, the World Cup. FIFA, the governing body for what we call soccer and what everybody else calls football, says 3.6 billion people watched at least some portion of the last tournament, held in Russia in 2018. That was nearly half the world’s population then.

Sports rivalries parallel international divisions

Then move onto the negatives – the fan violence, the corruption and the rivalries that all too closely parallel dangerous sectarian and religious rifts.

World Cup reality check: We can't ignore human rights issues plaguing soccer's biggest event and host country Qatar

Soccer or football?: An ignorant American’s guide to the World Cup

And consider FIFA. Yes FIFA, the organization that preaches coming together but serves as a platform for autocracy’s grievances against democracy. It is not a stretch to argue that the attention it lavished on dictator Vladimir Putin at the 2018 World Cup, which came four years after he had illegally annexed part of Ukraine, helped encourage his decision to mount a full-on invasion this February.

It is also perfectly reasonable to point out that keeping this year’s World Cup in Qatar after it had been determined that graft had been involved in the original decision creates a perverse incentive going forward.

So it is no surprise that this year’s tournament, coming at a turbulent moment in history, would unfold to humongous audiences, touching stories and multiple controversies. Team USA goes into Saturday's match against Netherlands after having beat back a sporting and geopolitical siege from Iran. And periodic protests have broken out over Qatar’s abysmal record on human and labor rights.

Watching the USA-Iran game on Nov. 29, 2022, at the World Cup in Doha, Qatar.
Watching the USA-Iran game on Nov. 29, 2022, at the World Cup in Doha, Qatar.

A catalyst for change

Nonetheless, the good news is that the World Cup is breaking through. Not the World Cup of false equivalencies preached by FIFA, but the World Cup as it is actually happening, with real people playing soccer to the best of their abilities, much to the delight of billions. The evidence is that it is having some undeniable positives.

Opinions in your inbox: Get exclusive access to our columnists and the best of our columns every day

Its biggest impact could be in China, the mega-country once thought to be on an arc toward democracy but which has recently swung in the opposite direction. Protests over the government’s draconian and never-ending COVID-19 lockdowns have now grown so large as to pose a significant threat to the communist government.

One of the catalysts of theses protests has been the World Cup, specifically the sight on television of stadiums and plazas in Qatar filled with reveling, unmasked soccer fans.

Protesters against China's harsh COVID-19 restrictions march in Beijing on Nov. 28, 2022.
Protesters against China's harsh COVID-19 restrictions march in Beijing on Nov. 28, 2022.

People in significant parts of the country consider the ability to watch the World Cup something of a human right, making it hard for any regime to not show it and still argue that its power is legitimate and that it cares for its people. The Chinese government, as much as it may have wanted to, decided it couldn’t not air the event.

While Chinese state television is now editing out close-up scenes of fans, this only goes so far. It’s impossible to watch a World Cup game and not see the crowds. And it’s impossible to edit out all the maskless people, particularly those in the first few rows who often show up in the background as the game is being played.

Making a difference in Iran

Iran is another place where the World Cup appears to be having an impact. Protests there have been going on since September and have, like in China, picked up in recent days. The issue is also repressive government in general but specifically the treatment of women: Mahsa Amini, 22, was arrested for not being properly veiled and died in the custody of the so-called morality police.

We must take a stand for women: Iran's horrific situation feels a world away. It's not.

Iran's Gen Z is fed up: The protests aren't just about hijab, they're about regime change.

While there is no direct connection to the World Cup, the fact that Iran is a participant this year has focused international attention on that country and, therefore, the protests on its streets. Last Saturday, the U.S. soccer federation even posted Iran's national flag on social media without the emblem of the Islamic Republic, saying it supports Iranian protesters ahead of the two nations' World Cup match just days later. After pushback from Tehran, though, the federation deleted those social media posts.

Jason Rezaian, an American journalist who spent more than a year in Iranian prisons on trumped up charges, wrote in the Washington Post this week that he actually was hoping Iran would advance at the expense of Team USA because it would continue focusing attention on what is happening in Tehran and other cities.

Opinion alerts: Get columns from your favorite columnists + expert analysis on top issues, delivered straight to your device through the USA TODAY app. Don't have the app? Download it for free from your app store.

The World Cup is messy and chaotic, led by a troubled and pernicious governing body. The event often involves spending fortunes on stadiums that could better be used elsewhere.

Nevertheless, as it plays out it is hard to deny that this World Cup has been a force for good. Maybe that is why they call it the beautiful game.

Dan Carney is a former USA TODAY editorial writer.

More from Dan Carney:

England has often fared better with queens on the throne. Will Elizabeth II be its last?

A farewell to Donald Trump editorials and USA TODAY: It's been anything but tweed

You can read diverse opinions from our Board of Contributors and other writers on the Opinion front page, on Twitter @usatodayopinion and in our daily Opinion newsletter. To respond to a column, submit a comment to letters@usatoday.com.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: World Cup players, fans prove it's a force for good on China, Iran